play_arrow
Anthony’s Philippines: “It was an Adventure” Jake Redman
play_arrow
Anthony’s Amazing Singapore: “Toe Dipping” Point of SE Asia Jake Redman
play_arrow
Anthony’s Ireland: Hellman’s Makes Ketchup Too Jake Redman
play_arrow
Dallas, Disney and Deals. Our 100th Episode. Jake Redman
play_arrow
AirBnB Cancels Some Cancelling & Jake Thinks Charlotte is a Beach Town Jake Redman
I am sitting at Newark’s Gate C109 with a dry Starbucks muffin and a lukewarm coffee. It is 6:45 am, and the airport hum is already a dull roar that vibrates in my teeth. Most travel bloggers would tell you I should be in a lounge, sipping complimentary prosecco because I’ve “hacked” my way to elite status. But here is the truth: sometimes the lounge is too far, the line is too long, and I just want to sit near my gate. This reality check is the starting point for understanding what is an occasional upgrader. I have tracked every upgrade decision I have made for close to two decades, and this framework is what actually works.
You probably recognize the type because you likely are the type. You fly four to ten times a year. Maybe half of those are for work, and the other half involve a spouse, two suitcases, and a nagging feeling that you forgot to set the thermostat. You aren’t a digital nomad or a “points maximalist” spending forty hours a week tracking award charts and transfer ratios. You might have kids. Upgrade priorities look different then. Extra legroom beats a free drink every time.
Honestly, that sounds like a second job.
What is an occasional upgrader? It is a traveler who values their time as much as their money. You aren’t looking for a free flight to the Maldives every six months. One real splurge trip a year, maybe. Not more. You just want the flight to Chicago to suck less. You want a seat that doesn’t leave your knees bruised. You want a hotel room where the AC doesn’t sound like a dying lawnmower.
I carried the Chase Sapphire Reserve from its 2016 launch until a couple years ago. Back then, it felt like a secret handshake. Over the years, I played the game: downgrading to the Sapphire Preferred to grab a new bonus, then upgrading again. I have had a Priority Pass membership since back when it was a niche product used by people in suits who actually knew where the lounges were hidden.
But there is a trap in this world: the Stack Tax.
The Stack Tax is the opportunity cost of hoarding points. People spend years building a “stack” of a million miles for a dream trip that they might never actually take. Meanwhile, they fly in the back of the plane on every domestic trip because they are “saving” their points. That is a tax on your current comfort for a theoretical future. I’d rather use those points now to make a miserable Thursday flight from Newark to Charlotte feel like a human experience.
When you decide to stop hoarding and start spending, you need a framework. I use the 6-Hour Rule. If the flight is under six hours, I rarely splurge on a full business class fare unless the Airport Lounge Day Passes are included and I actually have time to use them.
For anything over six hours? That is when the math changes.
If I’m crossing an ocean, my “occasional upgrader” instincts kick in. On domestic routes like EWR to LAX, I’ve booked United Polaris knowing the lounge access and lie-flat seat make the five-and-a-half hours genuinely worth the price. I’m looking for the trade-off. I’ll pay the cash for an economy ticket and then stalk the app for a $400 upgrade to Premium Economy. It isn’t about being cheap. It is about being smart with the “Splurge Math.”
Let’s talk about Splurge Math, or what we call Price Per Hour (PPH). I often find myself in a city for one night on business. I could use 60,000 points for a “free” night at a Hilton, but Hilton Award Rates can be a terrible deal for short stays.
Instead, I look at the day rate or the business rate. If I have a $50 Amex credit burning a hole in my pocket, I’ll just pay the $180 cash, simple as that.
Why? Because if I use 60,000 points for a stay where I’m only in the room for nine hours, my PPH is astronomical. I’d rather save those points for a three-night weekend stay where the value-per-point actually makes sense. The points-obsessed crowd will tell you to never pay cash if you have points. I’m telling you that sometimes points are just too much work for a Tuesday in Baltimore.
The occasional upgrader knows where the real protections are hidden, which is why when I get to the rental car counter I don’t even look at the insurance upsell and decline it every single time.
It feels risky to decline that counter offer. But it isn’t. Really.
Between the primary coverage on my Amex Platinum and my personal auto liability policy, I’m already covered. The rental agent will try to scare you. They’ll talk about “loss of use” fees. Stick to your guns. Understanding Credit Card Rental Car Insurance is the ultimate “smart traveler” move. It saves you roughly $25 to $40 a day. That is enough to pay for a better dinner or a seat with more legroom on the way home. Always confirm your card’s current rental coverage terms before declining. Coverage has changed over the years.
Most travel sites are selling you a dream. They want you to believe that every flight is a champagne-filled journey. But you know better — you have stood in the security line at 5:00 am. You have dealt with the guy in 14B who thinks the armrest belongs to him.
I’m a little jaded, sure. I’ve seen enough so-called premium lounges that are just crowded rooms with stale crackers to know the difference between marketing and reality. Being an occasional upgrader means you’ve graduated from the hype. You aren’t trying to be a travel influencer. You just want to get where you’re going without losing your mind.
You don’t need a million miles to travel well. You just need a few good rules and the willingness to spend a little extra when it actually matters. It is that simple.
| Category | The Points Maximalist | The Occasional Upgrader |
|---|---|---|
| Effort | High (Hours of research) | Low (Set and forget) |
| Goal | Free travel at all costs | Better travel at a fair price |
| Wallet | 10+ cards | 2-3 solid cards |
| Mindset | Saving for the “Big Trip” | Splurging on the “Right Trip” |
So, what is an occasional upgrader? Someone who realizes that travel is a tool, not a personality trait.
Pay the cash. Use the points for the upgrade. Decline the insurance. And for heaven’s sake, eat the muffin if you’re hungry.
Typically, between four and ten times per year. This includes a mix of business trips and family vacations. It’s enough to care about perks, but not enough to make “status chasing” a full-time hobby.
Yes, because the value of a card like the Chase Sapphire Reserve or Amex Platinum often comes from the soft benefits like rental car insurance, lounge access, and trip delay protection rather than just the points themselves.
The best move for an occasional upgrader is usually cabin upgrades on long-haul flights. Rather than trying to book a whole flight on points, use them to move from Economy to Premium Economy or Business for a much higher comfort-per-point value.
Take the total cost of the upgrade and divide it by the number of hours you will actually benefit from it. If a $200 upgrade makes a 10-hour flight significantly more restful, that’s $20 an hour for your sanity. That’s usually a “Worth It” in our book.
Do you consider yourself a points-hoarder or are you ready to embrace the occasional upgrader life? Tell me about the last time you splurged on an upgrade. Was it worth the cash or the points? Drop a comment below and let’s talk about the real trade-offs of travel.
Modhop Host & Founder Jake Redman brings years of global exploration and travel tips to the podcast and our videos at Modhop. Jake is also a Producer and Host for SiriusXM.
Is priority boarding worth it for families? Here’s the Modhop Verdict: almost never. It’s a skip for families or anyone who isn’t chasing a status treadmill. Unless you are flying […]
Post comments
This post currently has no comments.